Fostering Great Discussions and Improving Student Participation-Handout1

Greg Reihman, Lehigh University 3/17/2005

 

I. Establish the Conditions of the Possibility of Good Discussion

            Build participation into your course design

Make participation part of the course goals and course grade

Build in opportunities for participation

                        Schedule student questioners/facilitators

                        Plan for brief group presentations

                        Use problem-based learning or other projects that encourage participation

            Incorporate techniques and technologies (see below) into the course design

            Build in opportunities for frequent feedback (see below)

            Create a safe space for discussion

 

II. Teach Students How to Participate

Discuss participation goals and offer participation grading guidelines

            Write a participation contract together with students

            Revisit participation goals regularly

            Have 'ramping-up' discussionsÑgive frank feedback about how to improve

            Inspire good discussion

Give and Get Feedback

Meet early and frequently with students with special challenges

Midterm assessment (of the class, by the students)

Midterm participation self-assessment (of the student, by the student)

Assessment (by you or by students) after a student presentation or facilitation

 

 

III. Initiate and Sustain Quality Discussions

Get students to say something, anything, on the first day.

Get everyone on the same page at the start of each class.

Start with a good question, a provocative thesis, or two competing theses.

-Good questions are open ended, ill defined, and important. They invite authentic problem solving.

-Don't fear silence.

-Give students a minute to freewrite before or after you pose the question.

Listen to the student's response.

-If their response is poorly put, ask a clarifying question or paraphrase what you think they said. Get something good on the table, but don't yet agree or disagree.

Promote student-student response

-Don't react immediately; invite other students to respond.

-Look or move around the room while the first student is still speaking

-Invite reactions to the contribution. If none come, invite some comparisons with or connections to specific earlier contributions from other students, or to the reading.

Engage the student

-When you engage an individual student, press for explanations, examples, evidence, supporting arguments, examples, counterexamples

-Know whether to push, how hard to push, and when to let Ôem off the hook.